BenLaGuer.com

The "Likelier Suspect"

Home
Tragedy Times Two (Valley Advocate 4/5/07)
What's At Stake in Commonwealth v. LaGuer
The Anatomy of a Political Hit
Errors in the Ben LaGuer DNA Analysis
VIDEO
Filings & Rulings Since February 11, 2004
DNA Reports & Chain of Custody Documents
DNA Experts Statements
John Silber's Statement to the Parole Board (6/12/03)
Testimonials
TIMELINE (1978 - 2004)
Sen. Dianne Wilkerson Demands Accountability
Sen. Barrios Writes to State Police
Arroyo/Turner Letter to Judge Hillman
Six State Representatives Ask State Police Three Questions (6/13/03)
Rep. Ellen Story Follows Up & Gwen Pino Responds
Rep. Ellen Story Offers an Agenda
Recent Coverage
Magazine & News Articles 1984 - 1996
Television News 1989 - 2003
Associated Press (coverage)
Boston Globe (coverage)
Telegram & Gazette (coverage)
Sentinel & Enterprise (coverage)
Boston Herald (coverage)
Springfield Republican (coverage)
Judge Timothy Hillman's orders to preserve documents
Northeastern University Collects LaGuer Papers
Quarantined Behind Stone and Steel
May 2004 - January 2007 Calendar Showing Major Events
FOIA Campaign
LINKS
PHOTOS & AUDIO (Oral Arguments Nov. 2005)
ADA Sandra Hautenan Misstates the Factual Record
PHOTOS (Parole Hearing June 2003)
Visitor Survey
fingerprint_report_4lines.jpg

_________________________________________

Whose Were They?

Police Retreived 4 Fingerprints from a Trimline Phone, the Cord of which was used to Bind the Victim's Ankles. Tpr Arthur Martin Compared them to LaGuer's "with neg results".

The Evidence Says:

 

Jose Orlando Gomez

Gomez_photo.jpg
Jose Gomez (early 1990's)

 

The Evidence....

Martinez_report_p7.jpg
click to enlarge

 
 
1983
Gomez is identified as "likelier suspect" but police never question him.
 
 
 

Martinez_report_p7_zoom.jpg

Soon after the crime was committed private investigators identified Jose Gomez as a "likelier suspect." Of similar build and complexion to LaGuer he had access to the apartment complex. Unlike LaGuer, Gomez had a history of sexual misconduct. One investigator independently verified that Gomez had been sent to Worcester State Hospital for that reason.

Worcester_hospital_postcard2.jpg
click for link

Worcester_State_Hospital.jpg
Worcester State Hospital

Anecdotal evidence points to Jose Gomez: Juror William Nowick's statement in a 7/12/89 article by Andrew Baron (Why Can't This Man Get A New Trial?). The victim's courtroom testimony as noted in Richard Nangle's October 1986 series.
 
 

Nowick_Worcester_mag.jpg
click to enlarge

Nangle_graph.jpg
click to enlarge

Waterways_entrance.jpg
Waterways entrance

Gomez' mother, Felicita, had lived in the Waterways, so he knew the building. Leominster Spanish American Center director Neddy Latimer says Gomez was acting erratically around the time of the crime. He allegedly burst into the fire station yelling "nobody will help me, they treat me like I have the plague." She said Felicita Gomez sought counseling for her son for sexually assaulting family members.

 

 

Martinez_report_p7_mother.jpg
from investigators' report

 
______________________________________
1991

Gomez Allegedly Twice Tells Bartender Nancy Martinez (no relation to investigator of the same name) That He Committed The Crime

 

Secret_memorandum_p1_zoom1.jpg

JC_Fenwicks.jpg
formerly the Plymouth Cafe

Gomez_photo_tighter.jpg

Notes kept by attorney John LaChance allege that a Nancy Martinez heard Gomez' confession. The owner of J.C. Fenwicks confirmed that he had a bartender of that name in the early 1990s.
 
 
 
 

__________________________________
1998
Gomez Arrested for Rape!

Gomez_arrest.jpg
click to enlarge

gomez_sentencing.jpg
click to enlarge

 

In May 1998, a few weeks before LaGuer's first parole hearing, Jose Orlando Gomez was arrested and charged with the crime of rape (above). His brother, who also has an alleged rape charge on record, posted bail. Gomez hired a lawyer. On the day of the trial the rape charge was dropped in a plea bargain with DA John Conte's office.  He served 59 days in prison (left).

 

 

 

______________________________
 
LaGuer_prints_sliver2.jpg
2001
Police Release the Front (but not the back) of a Fingerprint Report 18 Years After the Fact

LaGuer_prints.jpg

fingerprint_report_trim.jpg
click to enlarge

LaGuer voluntarlily accompanied police to the station on July 15, 1983 to answer questions about the attack on his neighbor. The police told him they had recovered fingerprints from the crimes scene. LaGuer gave the police a set of his fingerprints (left) for comparison. The report prepared the next day (right) shows the prints in question did NOT match LaGuer's. Police and prosecutors withheld this information for more than 18 years until November 2001.
 

Fingerprint_response.jpg
click to enlarge

 
 
In an email (left) to LaGuer's lawyer, assistant district attorney Sandra Hautanen claimed to have no knowledge of why the back of the report, which may show the actual fingerprints retreived from the crime scene, is missing.
 
 
 
 
 
 

LaGuer_prints_sliver2.jpg

 
______________________________________________
2003 / 2004
Jose Gomez is Still With His Mother
 

Soon after the brutal crime was committed reports surfaced that the true perpetrator would be apprehended once his mother is located. Evidence suggests this is still the case twenty three years later. Jose Gomez lived in Leominster until a few years ago....

Gomez_restraining.jpg
click to enlarge

....when he was summonsed for violating a restraining order in 1999 he lived at 143 Meadowbook Lane in Fitchburg. He still lives there. With his mother!

eric_goldscheider.jpg
Eric Goldscheider

To_SP_Kelly.jpg
click to enlarge

Freelance reporter Eric Goldscheider, who edits this Web site, contacted Leominster Police Chief Peter Roddy to ask for a meeting regarding the LaGuer case. Goldscheider followed up with this June 17, 2003 letter to State Police Lt. Col. John Kelly. He never responded.